DRAFT
Regular Meeting July 11, 2005
Charlton Town Board
Saratoga County
New York
After the pledge to the flag, the invocation was given by
Town Clerk Gail Hanchar.
At the regular meeting of the Town Board of Charlton, Saratoga County, New York held at
7:30 P.M. at the Charlton Town Hall, called to order by
Supervisor Acunto, there were present:
Councilman Robert
Lippiello
Councilman Dorothy
Mitchell
Councilman Sandra Verola
Supervisor Ferdinand
Acunto
Councilman Grattidge was excused.
Motion made by Councilman Verola, seconded by Councilman
Mitchell that the minutes of the June 13 Town Board Meeting and the June 27
Agenda Meeting be accepted as received:
PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
Approved: Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
ABSTRACT OF CLAIMS:
The total of the bills approved for the July abstract was
$32,656.54.
Vouchers for the month were #1554 - #1648.
Corrections for the July abstract:
Voucher #1562 to Charlton Septic Service was for a total
amount of $95.00.
Voucher #1622 to Charlton Water Dist. had an account code
change.
Voucher #1626 to BFI was deleted.
TOWN CLERK’S REPORT:
Gail Hanchar read the Town Clerk’s Report. She reported
taking in $182.45. Motion made by Councilman Verola, seconded by Councilman
Lippiello. PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
PRIVILEGE OF THE FLOOR (Agenda Items):
No comments.
SUPERVISOR’S REPORT AND ANNOUNCEMENTS:
June revenue and expenditures:
General Fund – Expenditures of $55,369.86. Revenue of
$17,324.72.
Highway Fund – Expenditures of $27,083.66. Revenue of
$82,428.24.
Water District #1 – Expenditures of $9,246.20. Revenue of
$1,608.83.
Water District #2 – Expenditures of $174.66. No revenue.
Major revenue:
General Fund - Safety Inspections of $2,747.00, Planning
Board Fees of $1,300.00, Interest and Earnings of $2,400.00 and Fines and
Forfeited Bail of $9,619.99.
Highway Fund – Sales Tax Distribution of $81,462.00 and
Interest and Earnings of $966.24.
Major expenditures:
General Fund – Legislative Contractual of $1,627.10,
Buildings-Operation of Plant (for Mr. Vosburgh) of $4,675.86, Police
Contractual (for radio repair) of $1,320.78, Ambulance Contractual of
$3,000.00, Joint Youth Program of $3,000.00 and Drainage (for Legal Notice and
Engineering-MS4 Program ) of $2,677.11.
Highway Fund – Road Construction (for preparation of paving)
of $1,437.80 and Machinery Contractual of $1,262.10.
Water Fund – Transmission and Distribution of $2,785.00 and
Engineering (for Little Troy alternate water) of $3,439.08.
Web site activity for the month of June was 798 hits.
The County GIS System is now accessible to everyone. The
address is: www.maphost.com/saratoga
or www.co.saratoga.ny.us
At the June Agenda, the Charlton Seniors requested the Town
purchase a van for the seniors.
The Board has decided a van will be purchased in 2006.
Supervisor Acunto stated his position of the Saratoga County
Water System, a system that is taking the water out of the Hudson River and
developing a county wide water system. “I support the project as it is
intended. What concerns me is that there have been some major expenditures in
preparation for the upcoming project. The problem is, as I look at the
numbers, the system cannot support itself. There are not enough users
(municipalities) that are signed on. To float the bond that would have to pay
for this without enough users would mean an ad valorem tax to every tax
payer/resident within the county even if you don’t use the water. Charlton is
in that type of situation. We have our water source from the Town of Glenville. We are paying an ad valorem. Right now the way the system is designed,
Charlton is not going to be able to be part of the county-wide water system but
we might have to suffer an ad valorem tax because it would need to be made to
pay the bond. I am on record as opposing it. Several other supervisors have
stated the same. We are in the minority right now. I am not supporting any
more funding of this project until I am assured that this system can pay its
own way. By that I mean that the users will be able to support the system. If
anyone has any concerns and feels that this is not a direction they would like
to see me going in, I would be glad to talk to anyone.”
Councilman Verola stated that it was her understanding that
people who are currently in the water district in town would still have to pay
the ad valorem tax for Saratoga County even though they are already hooked up
to water. Supervisor Acunto said you would be paying two, the one we are
already getting service from and the proposed County system.
Regarding the traffic light at Route 146 and Route 67, there
was a double fatality at that intersection several weeks ago. The issue with
the light has been that if there was a power surge or a loss of power, the
light would go into a flashing mode of red in one direction and yellow in the
other. Supervisor Acunto spoke with DOT and asked if it could go on flashing
red in all directions. He also spoke with the Fire Department and the police
with little satisfaction. He then went to the media and as a result, when
there is a power problem, the light will flash red in all directions. It is now
considered a primary intersection instead of a secondary intersection. As a
secondary intersection, if there was a problem after 5:00 P.M. on Friday, it didn’t get repaired until Monday. Now it will be fixed within 4 hours of
notification.
On July 27 at 7:00 P.M. there will be a concert in Gideon Hawley Park sponsored by the Historical Society and the Town.
We received a request from a private agency asking us to put
an advertisement on our web page. Our policy is that we will not allow any
advertising or links on the web page for commercial purposes. The web page is
strictly for Town business. We will accept links to other municipal
organizations.
We have received notification from New York State that Senator Farley has been able to get a $20,000.00 grant for the Town for a generator
or any other Town project that we see as a priority. If it is for a specific
piece of equipment, they need to know make, model, name, etc. Supervisor
Acunto feels we might be better served to earmark that money for some other
project within the construction of the Town Hall. Sandy and Alan will discuss
it report at the Agenda Meeting.
COMMUNICATIONS:
We received notification from DOT that they have received
our request for a speed reduction on Maple Avenue and Featherbed Lane.
We received a thank you note from the Bagdan family thanking
the Town Board for our resolution recognizing dairy farmers.
The Board is invited to meet with the Fire Commissioners on
July 21 at 7:00 P.M. at the fire house. They would like the Town Board to
review the plans for their new fire house.
The Town Clerk’s Office and Bookkeeper’s Office will be
professionally cleaned on Wednesday. We had an air conditioner put in the bookkeeper’s office. Both offices were affected by dirt and dust and insulation falling from
the ceiling.
ASSESSMENT REVIEW BOARD:
Eva Butler reported there were 16 complaints dealing with 19
properties. Four were reduced. The rest remained unchanged. They approved 19
stipulations. There was 1 correction due to a clerical error.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN:
Nan has finished going over the recommendations for the
sub-committees regarding the strategies for the 14 goals. Currently a system
for on-line voting by the committee members for the strategies is being set
up. They will be meeting the lst Monday in August.
CONSTABLES:
For the month of June there were 23 patrols, answered 3 911
calls, covered 1,654 miles, issued 29 tickets and investigated 2 accidents.
ECC:
They met in June and considered 2 variance requests from the
ZBA. They will be heard tomorrow night.
E-GOVERNMENT:
The CMS server is up and running. John Kelley is getting it
configured to fit our web site. He wants to pilot it himself for a while to
make sure everything is alright. As we feed in areas one by one, this will
allow individual committees to update their section of the web site without
having to go through the web master. There will be various levels of access to
the web site where someone could post it and someone else would have the
authority to allow it to go live onto the web site. Our next meeting is August
10.
EMERGENCY PLANNING:
Hank Coghill has resigned from the committee due to lack of
activity. The Committee is planning to meet this month.
HIGHWAY:
We will be awarding a bid for a gas-powered tamper.
Paving will hopefully begin the beginning of next week. It
will depend on the Cady Company being on site. They have been held up by the
weather. We will be doing DeGraff Road, Lasher Road and Dawson Road.
In previous years the Highway Department had been picking up
brush left at the roadside. We have now contracted with County Waste. Every Thursday they will pick up leaves and brush from all residents at no charge.
Since that has started, we have been getting phone calls from residents saying
they have larger brush. The Town gravel bank on Route 67 can accept larger
brush but not stumps and logs. It is available to any Town resident. Call the
Highway Department before dumping brush so they can tell you where they want it
to be placed.
HISTORIAN:
On June 29 the Historians of Saratoga County and County Historian met with the Local Government Records Management Officer for our area,
Dave Lowry, to teach Historians about the care of their records and town
records.
The County is currently working on gathering more
information on the Underground Railroad and the role of Saratoga County in that era of history and learning more about the black experience in Saratoga County.
The annual Solomon Northup Day is July 16.
On July 1 Historians within Saratoga County were invited to Brookside Museum for a story swap. They each brought a news article from their town from
100 years ago and talked about what was going on.
There is have an exhibit at Brookside called “Jumping
Through Hoops” about the fashion industry in Saratoga County.
There is a “Dressing for the Racetrack” exhibit at the Schenectady Museum.
The theme this summer for the Saratoga County Fair is
“Health, History and Horses”.
Last weekend the Charlton Historical Society held a garden
tour.
The Historical Society Museum on Maple Avenue is open each
weekend.
The Saratoga Plan has a dinner meeting on July 14. They
will be recognizing the Saratoga County Board of Supervisors for developing a
county-wide green infrastructure plan. This a topic among historians as they
have been asked to work with their town’s Comprehensive Plan which involves
open space.
The historians have a booth at the Saratoga County Fair.
On July 20 at 7:00 P.M. at the Charlton Town Hall, the Historic District Commission is having John Sherer, the Clifton Park Historian,
talk about historic districts and historic work in the Town of Clifton Park.
It is open to the public.
This year’s annual Capital Area Archives Dinner will be held
October 6. The topic will be Inadequate Record Keeping-Ethical Dilemma’s. The
Professor of History from Boston College will be presenting his work in
Religious Archives of the Catholic Church in the Boston area.
HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION:
They will be meeting on July 20 at the Town Hall.
LIBRARY:
They held their annual meeting a week ago. They will have a
regular meeting the end of the month.
PARK COMMITTEE:
They have been working on a grant proposal. There will be a
resolution.
Supervisor Acunto received a request from the Capital
District Transportation Committee to update our parks on a map. George said we
have an aerial photograph supplied by a volunteer.
RECORDS ADVISORY BOARD:
They met last week. We have concerns regarding the
condition of the room upstairs and the quality of the air for anyone working up
there with our records. Heather will be getting an estimate of what it would
cost to have the room cleaned. We also discussed the possibility of putting
plastic on the walls that are open to the studs to keep the records cleaner.
At our next meeting we will review the different types of grants that are
available and determine which one would be most appropriate. The Town has a
contract with Susan Lombardi to research grants. We may use her in the
process. We want to get our records cleaned and in good order before they go
to the new building. We will be attending classes.
TECHNOLOGY BOARD:
John Kelley attended their last meeting. They reviewed
backing up the Town Clerk’s records.
They are working on a technology plan and a budget request
for 2006. John Kelley will donate a CD burner for the Town Clerk’s Office for
backup. Ron Gavin asked the Board to review a maintenance package system for
his equipment.
TOWN HALL:
Councilman Verola expressed her thanks to Senator Farley for
his contribution to the Town Hall. She has also been in contact with
Congressman Sweeney’s Office and is waiting to hear from them.
We should have the final report on the archeological dig
early in August.
WATER:
Clean up has begun where the push will go under the Alplaus
so the companies can get in there and see what has to be done when they look at
the site for bidding.
We are checking the chlorination on a daily basis.
ZBA:
They have two hearings tomorrow night starting at 7:30 P.M.
ZONING:
For the month of June building fees were $2,663.00. Zoning
fees were $550.00.
RESOLUTIONS:
Motion made by Councilman Lippiello, seconded by Councilman
Verola that
Resolution #101, A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ADVERTISING
FOR SEALED BIDS FOR INSTALLATION OF AN ALTERNATE WATER DISTRICT TRANSMISSION
LINE ACROSS THE ALPLAUSKILL, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Absent
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Resolution #102, A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE SUPERVISOR TO
ENTER INTO A CONTRACT FOR THE INSTALLATION OF A MONITORING SYSTEM AND
MONITORING SERVICE AT THE WATER DISTRICT PUMP STATION, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Absent
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Lippiello, seconded by Councilman
Mitchell that
Resolution #104, A RESOLUTION APPOINTING DONALD
SCHERMERHORN, JOEL LANDIS AND KEITH FITZGERALD AS FINANCE COMMITTEE MEMBERS, be
approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Absent
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Lippiello, seconded by Councilman
Mitchell that
Resolution #105, A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE SUPERVISOR TO
FILE A GRANT APPLICATION FOR FUNDING FROM THE NYS OFFICE OF PARKS, RECREATION
AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION, be approved:
Councilman Lippiello stated that the $13,869.00 is a matching
grant which we will be responsible for next year. One of the major components
of it is a new pavilion to replace the one in Elmer Smith Park. Also included
is a backstop for a new ball field, repair work on the warming shed, picnic
tables and park benches.
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Absent
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Verola, seconded by Councilman
Mitchell that Resolution #106, A RESOLUTION TO AWARD A BID FOR A PLATE TAMPER
FOR THE HIGHWAY DEPARTMENT, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Absent
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
COUNCILMAN REPORTS:
Councilman Verola – Nothing more.
Councilman Mitchell – Nothing more.
Councilman Lippiello – John has been busy getting the
material ready to go for the bid that went out tonight.
Supervisor Acunto – At our last Agenda Meeting we appointed
a Broker of Record for health insurance.
PRIVILEGE OF THE FLOOR:
Marv Schorr – Imperial Lane – On behalf of the Charlton
Seniors he thanked the Town Board for the action taken on a van. Marv
explained that the Office of the Aging will reimburse the Town 75% of the cost.
John Tasse – Sweetman Road – Asked if Saratoga Lake is off the table as a source of water for the Saratoga County Water System. Supervisor
Acunto stated that the County’s proposal is for the Hudson River. The city is
pushing Saratoga Lake. Marv Schorr said that in order for it to be
self-supporting, enough towns have to buy into it and then the need for an ad
valorem tax would go away.
John Tasse asked what the purpose of the second water line
would be. Councilman Lippiello said the line has been under the Alplaus for 30
years. There is some concern that it might start to deteriorate. If there is
ever an emergency, we have isolated the northern half of the town. This is a
secondary line to bring water up over the creek. This would be a second path
parallel to the exiting path.
John Tasse asked if we have specifications for the Town Hall
in hand yet for people to look at. Councilman Verola said that she and Alan
will be meeting with Mr. Vosburgh hopefully next week and try and get to the
specifications. Because of the archeological dig, it has put a hold on
everything.
John feels we should appoint someone in the building trade
as Clerk of the Works. They could go through the specs. and see where we could
save some money. I am almost positive $7,000.00 is a lot of money for a
generator. Maybe we could not put historical siding on right off. Maybe there
are ideas to get the price down by going through the specs. before the building
cycle. Supervisor Acunto said the Board has had discussions about that and at
what time to bring a clerk of the works, etc. in. It has to be part of the
funding package that will be put out to the public to vote on. Councilman
Verola said that when we get the specifications we will definitely ask someone
to look at them.
John asked that as a result of the audit, was there any
global evaluation of the Town’s ability to do what it is planning to do with
the town hall. Was there any review of cash flow? Supervisor Acunto said no.
That audit was done for the year 2004. It had nothing to do with projections.
It is on file in the Town Clerk’s office. John asked if as a result of the
audit, we can execute the town hall and still meet the bills? Supervisor
Acunto said that was not part of the audit but we hired Jeanine Caruso to look
into that. She did a presentation at a Town Board Meeting and prepared a
package for us.
John asked what specifically is the new Finance Committee?
Supervisor Acunto said they are an advisory committee made up of people who
have a finance background who will be in a position if the board wants some
advisory opinions. We have to prepare for GASB #34 which will soon be part of
our annual audit. Kathy will need some help in putting that together.
John asked what the status was of the chlorine sampling.
There was a concern. Supervisor Acunto said it has been fluctuating.
Councilman Lippiello said John as been taking samples. North of the tank there
is chlorine in the water but it is low. John met with the state engineer. She
has asked him to continue with the testing and reporting. She will pass the
results on to her supervisor. The bacterial tests have all come back fine. At
the last Agenda Meeting we approved funds so John could begin working with EDP
should we need a chlorination system.
John asked if there had been any news on the lawsuit for Crooked Street? Supervisor Acunto said it is at the appellate level. We are waiting.
John said that since his wife was the former Zoning
Administrator, they have gotten about 15 calls over the past month of people
trying Leslie in desperation because they can’t reach Dave. They say the phone
acts like it is disconnected. They get no answer. They aren’t getting a voice
mail. This was an issue with Dave when he got fired the first time from that
position, that he wouldn’t get back to people. Supervisor Acunto said his
phone hasn’t been ringing.
Laura asked if there would be a way of putting the Charlton
Directory on line since we currently do not have anyone doing it? Supervisor
Acunto said he is concerned because there could be many people that would not
want that information on the web page. Councilman Mitchell said they had
planned on doing it last year but it didn’t happen due to illness. She will
check on it.
Gerry Belisle – Stage Road – Read a letter from the Charlton
Democratic Committee asking the Town Board to state its position on the
following issues: (1) slowing the pace of development in Charlton until the
Comprehensive Development Plan is finished and
(2) policies governing the issuance of building permits for
parcels within the town. To elaborate on each issue: (1) Steve Caine,
Chairman of the Comprehensive Planning Committee, indicated hope that a draft
document could be out the end of the year. Would the Town Board consider
placing a moratorium on new construction until the adoption of a Comprehensive
Development Plan? To allow a rush to build in order to escape possible
restrictions once the Comprehensive Plan is adopted would be short-sighted and
could result in what the majority of Charlton residents consider undesirable
development. (2) This concern relates to potential violations of DEC
identified wetland development regulations within the town and the serious
question of issuance of inappropriate permits. Presently at least two
instances of questionable, and possibly inappropriate, building permit
approvals are known. In some cases the minimum requirement of 2 acres for new
building has been disregarded or easily waived. For the property at the
southeast corner of Division Street and Route 67 NYSDEC has written, “A DEC
permit will not be issued for this site, as it would, in essence, validate an
illegal activity.” Is the Town Board satisfied with the performance and
actions of the currently appointed Building Inspector and Zoning Board
Administrator?
Marv Schorr stated that there is no date for the completion
of the Comprehensive Plan that has been agreed to by the Comprehensive Planning
Committee. The Town doesn’t administer the wetlands laws, the State does.
Supervisor Acunto said that the Board had a meeting with DEC on that particular
project and they have given out a permit for that parcel. We will address
these and make some kind of response. I’m not promising it will be in the next
30 days.
Suzanne Voigt – Dawson Road – A few months ago she brought
to the Board’s attention that there was a bridge in Mill Pond Park that had
boards that were about to give way. They have given way. The bridge is
missing three boards. She said she was told by Mr. Grattidge that he would
look into it. She told him a month ago that the boards had given way. George
said he spoke with Ron after their April walk through. Councilman Lippiello
said the Board was concerned if people were taking horses through that area.
The bridge was not made to take horse traffic. Suzanne said that had always
been a horse path through there and was used by bikes, snowmobiles, etc. The
Board will speak to Ron about it.
Ray Simboli – Old Stage Road - Asked if the Board would
consider a finite date for the Comprehensive Plan so that it doesn’t remain
open-ended.
Councilman Mitchell feels the Comprehensive Plan is moving
forward. They have gone through all of the recommendations and will be voting
on those. There is a light at the end of the tunnel. Councilman Verola asked
if it would be advisable to put a completion date on the project. Marv Schorr
stated that if you look at the overall process, the plan would only be a series
of recommendations. Assuming the Town accepts the Comprehensive Plan, the
Zoning Ordinance Review Committee then has to take that work and change the
Zoning Ordinance. That could take a couple of years. The last major revision
to the Zoning Ordinance took three years. I don’t think you want to put a
building moratorium on for three or four years. Even if you set a date for
completion of the Comprehensive Plan, and I don’t know why you would want to do
that other than for closure, you still have the whole process of changing the
Zoning Ordinance to implement the recommendations of the plan which is what the
plan is, a series of recommendations. Councilman Verola said there would also
be public hearings involved with the Town Board.
Ray Simboli said that since there are a lot of things that
need to happen, he would suggest we start thinking about dates and setting
goals. (Changed tape.) The whole community was involved with the survey.
People were excited. The more time that goes by and nothing is acted upon or
reported upon, we will start loosing that energy. Supervisor Acunto said he
does not feel we are loosing energy. The Comprehensive Plan Committee is
meeting religiously and all of their work is on the web page. Councilman
Lippiello stated that we had professional help with the initiation of this and
it was not one of her recommendations that they establish a completion date.
Marv stated that the Comprehensive Planning Committee wants
to work as expeditiously as possible. The Comprehensive Plan is supposed to
be a 20-year plan. It will be what we want to see Charlton look like 20 years
out in time.
Suzanne stated that if you wait 5 to 10 years to get it done
you aren’t going to have the Charlton to work with that you want in 20 years.
Resident – I do a lot of long term work with different
groups all around the country and it is advisable to have some kind of a time
frame when you are talking about long term planning.
Marv said we have a time frame of roughly 18 months.
Suzanne said she became concerned at the Historical Society
Meeting with the farmers. They said they had “x” amount of acres and they rent
“x” amount of acres. It became apparent that without the rented acres, they
cannot keep farming. They are loosing some of that leasable land and can’t
afford to buy it. The only way they could afford to buy it would be through
grants. The only way you can apply for most grants applicable to farm land
purchases is if the Town has a Comprehensive Plan. We are fighting a time
issue. We will loose the Charlton we love.
After everyone had the opportunity to speak who wished, the
meeting was adjourned
at 9:15 P.M.
Respectfully
submitted,
Gail Hanchar
Town
Clerk