DRAFT
Regular Meeting May 9, 2005
Charlton Town Board
Saratoga County
New York
After the pledge to the flag the invocation was given by
Town Clerk Gail Hanchar.
At the regular meeting of the Town Board of Charlton, Saratoga County, New York held at
7:30 P.M. at the Charlton Town Hall, called to order by
Supervisor Acunto, there were present:
Councilman Alan
Grattidge
Councilman Robert
Lippiello
Councilman Dorothy
Mitchell
Councilman Sandra Verola
Supervisor Ferdinand
Acunto
Motion made by Councilman Grattidge, seconded by Councilman
Verola that the minutes of the April 11 Town Board Meeting and the April 25
Agenda Meeting be accepted as received:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge
Councilman
Lippiello
Councilman
Mitchell
Councilman
Verola
Supervisor
Acunto
ABSTRACT OF CLAIMS:
The following corrections were made to the abstract:
Voucher #1364 to The Daily Gazette had an account code
change.
Voucher #1371 to Suburban Energy Services was deleted for
double payment.
Voucher #1387 to Alpha Geo Science had an account code
change.
Voucher #1397 to Rain or Shine Tent Co. was deleted and will
be placed on June abstract.
Voucher #1402 to Empire State Fireworks was deleted and will
be placed on June abstract.
The total of the May Abstract was $37,784.36
Vouchers for the month were #1363 - #1441.
TOWN CLERK’S REPORT:
Gail Hanchar read the Town Clerk’s Report. She reported
taking in $145.23. Motion made by Councilman Grattidge, seconded by Councilman
Verola. PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
PRIVILEGE OF THE FLOOR (Agenda Items):
Don Schermerhorn from the Audit Committee gave a
presentation on the status of the audit.
He said that after discussions it was determined that: (1)
the Town Board should release the Independent Auditor from the preparation of
the GASB 34 portion of the audit, (2) that asset depreciation schedules be
prepared and guidelines/policies be established, (3) that the Town Board
dissolve the appointed Auditor Search Committee and (4) that at the
recommendation of Donna Farrar Lead Auditor, the Town Board give serious
consideration to establishing a permanent Audit and Finance Committee to assist
the Town Board.
SUPERVISOR’S REPORT AND ANNOUNCEMENTS:
April expenditures and revenue:
General Fund – Revenue of $12,695.13. Expenditures of
$49,882.97.
Highway Fund – Revenue of $870.76. Expenditures of
$42,038.28.
Water District #1 – Revenue of $1,473.84. Expenditures of
$5,112.90.
Water District #2 – Revenue of $6.39
Major revenue:
General Fund – Major portion was from Interest and Penalties
and Interest and Earnings.
Highway Fund – Interest and Earnings of $870.76.
Major expenditures:
General Fund – Engineering Contractual of $712.50, Buildings
Operation and Plant Contractual of $22,615.72 and Police Contractual of $1,171.09.
Highway Fund – Maintenance of Roads Contractual of
$3,649.64, Machinery Contractual of $2,315.70, Hospital and Medical Insurance
of $6,171.17.
Water District #1 – Transmission and Distribution of
$4,291.89.
Water District #2 - $261.99.
There were 818 hits on the web site for the month of April.
The E-Government Seminar in Saratoga is on Friday.
The Veteran’s Float will be in the Founder’s Day Parade. If
any veterans would like to ride on the float, contact Supervisor Acunto.
The Flag Day Parade in Burnt Hills will be on June 9 at 6:30 P.M. Anyone is welcome to walk with the Town Board.
Mosquito “dunks” are available at the Town Hall at no
charge.
Niagara Mohawk is still compiling data on the sub-station on
Route 67. They will get back to us.
On Wednesday, May 11 there will be a demonstration for
Supervisors of the County GIS. The next step will be a training session for a
person from each municipality. Janet Reville is interested in attending for
Charlton but needs to know how long the training will be.
The Memorial Day Ceremony will be held at 2:00 P.M. in Gideon Hawley Park.
The Town Hall will be closed May 28-30.
Wayne Hedrick is donating time, labor and materials for new
window boxes at the Town Hall.
CORRESPONDENCE:
We received a thank you note from the Burnt Hills Ballston
Lake Schools thanking us for allowing them to use the building for their
presentation on the budget.
We received a letter from Harlan and McGee. They were
architects for a resident who applied for a building permit. They have
notified the Town that they are withdrawing their approval for the building
plans. The structure has not been constructed in accordance with their
approved design. They feel there are unsafe structural conditions. Rich Moon,
Town Building Inspector, has written to the owner of the property informing him
of a Stop Work Order until violations are corrected. Dave LaFountain will
contact the Town Attorney regarding the matter.
ANIMAL CONTROL OFFICER:
The Dog Enumeration is on going.
ASSESSMENT REVIEW BOARD:
They had a training session last week. Grievance Day is May
24 from 2:00 P.M. – 4:00 P.M. and 6:00 P.M. – 8:00 P.M.
ASSESSORS:
They are getting things ready for the Board of Assessment
Review. They have a meeting planned with them on May 17.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN:
-
As mentioned at the last meeting, our consultant has provided us a list
of recommended strategies to help us meet our goals. For the last couple of
months, we have been working in subcommittees to identify questions or concerns
about them.
-
The entire CPSC started meeting again as an entire group on May 2 to
start the process of listening and learning as Nan answers the questions the
subcommittees have asked, and to provide her rational for those strategies the
subcommittees may potentially modify or reject.
-
On May 2, we got to the end of Goal 2, with 12 more goals to go.
-
We would like to get through this phase of our work by the end of June,
if at all possible.
-
We have added an extra meeting this month on May 31 at 7:00 P.M. in the One Room School House. We will be meeting on June 6 here at the town
hall and will decide then if we are going to try to meet again in June.
-
Once we finish this educational phase we will go back into our
subcommittees to make our subcommittee’s final recommendations on what
strategies to accept, modify or reject.
-
We will then meet again as an entire group, and taking the work of the
individual subcommittees into account and our discussions together, decide on
the entire package of strategies.
-
I want to emphasis at this time that the only thing the CPSC has agreed
on is the Vision Statement and the 14 Goals.
-
Let me give you a sense of the challenge we face, but one I believe we
can meet.
-
I do not have to tell you how much our townspeople love Charlton, and
its uniqueness. As you know, we have a rather dense residential area to the
south, an historic and period hamlet, and beautiful farms and open space to the
east, west and north. Each area of Charlton is unique with differing characteristics.
-
In our workshops, surveys and focus groups it became very clear our
townspeople want to preserve Charlton’s unique character and they fear growth
that would change the nature of our town.
-
A major challenge for us is to find the best way to meet these clearly
defined community-wide goals of preserving our rural character, farms, open
spaces, our environmentally sensitive areas and period structures, while also
striking the right balance for respecting the rights of landowners, especially
large land owners who have the most of their personal capital at stake.
-
I think it is safe to say there is no one silver bullet nor one or two
measures you can take to achieve this kind of balance.
-
Our consultant has provided us numerous recommended strategies all aimed
at giving us what the majority of our townspeople say they want.
-
What our consultant is giving us is a list of options, many voluntary.
All are meant to take into account health, safety and the general welfare. To
a large extent, her recommended approach is based on the town having an array
of viable, alternative options for working towards meeting the community-wide
goals. They could be used by the town and the landowner or developer in a
cooperative way to look at each specific situation to find options and a
course of action that comes closest to meeting the community’s goals, while
preserving landowner’s rights.
-
If we were to step back and try to describe the nature of overall the
package of strategies our consultant suggested, I think it would be fair to
characterize them as a flexible and layered approach for striking a balance
between meeting the clearly defined community goals and the understandable
concerns and interests of important segment(s) of our community.
-
Hopefully, at the next meeting I can describe these to you a little more
fully, after the committee discusses them.
-
As I said at the beginning, the committee hasn’t yet made any decisions
on these matters.
-
We will soon be doing so, and then providing information about all this
material to our townspeople before coming to you for the final phases of this
process.
CONSTABLES:
For the month of April they had 32 patrols, answered 6 911
calls, traveled 2,715 miles, issued 27 tickets and investigated 1 accident.
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION COMMISSION:
They had a very successful Road-Side Clean Up Day on April
30 followed by the Annual Tree Give Away which was also very successful. All
the trees were gone in 20 minutes. Marv thanked the Town Board for their
continued support, thanked everyone who participated and thanked the Highway
Department for picking up all the bags that were left along the road. The
Charlton General Store supplied coffee. Refreshments were purchased from
Smith’s Farm Bakery.
E-GOVERNMENT ADVISORY BOARD:
Several members will be going to the E-Government Conference
on Friday. Their next meeting is Monday, May 16.
EMERGENCY PLANNING COMMITTEE:
They will be meeting next month.
HIGHWAY:
They are still picking up items from bulk pick up.
HISTORIAN:
Laura prepared a draft of a resolution for the Stauffers
which the Town Board has.
She brought three notebooks. One contained pictures of the
Memorial Day Service for the past 30+ years. One had pictures and a record of
the students who placed flags on the veteran’s graves. This activity started
in 1992. She also had a notebook containing information about the town’s
cemeteries.
Saturday students from the Burnt Hills Ballston Lake Middle School worked with Laura placing flags on the veteran’s graves that are in our town
cemeteries. We now have families that help year after year with their grown
children who participated when the program first began. The program was begun
by Rick Reynolds, a teacher at the middle school. Last year he was honored as the
Social Studies Teacher of the Year for the country by the DAR. He is now the
Historian for the Town of Ballston.
On April 22-23, Laura attended the Mid-Atlantic Regional
Archives Council Conference in Albany learning about issues to deal with
records keeping.
On May 1-3, the Association of Public Historian of NYS held
their annual training in Amsterdam. Over 150 historians attended. The featured
speaker was Russell Shorto, author of “Island in the Center of the World” which
is about the founding of Manhattan.
On May 5 Laura attended an Electronic Documents Imaging
Course presented by the NYS Archives.
Brookside Museum is about the open an exhibit called
“Jumping Through Hoops, Fashion and Industry in Saratoga County”. They are
trying to find out what kind of fashion industries were in the Saratoga County area in the 1860’s, 1870’s and 1880’s. At that time there were over 5,000
sheep in Charlton. Many yard goods were being made in Charlton. (Changed tape)
Our Historical Society is having a meeting Wednesday night
at the Nadoraski’s home. We will be learning about the history and every day
life of our town’s dairy farmers. Our dairy farmers will be the grand marshals
of our Founder’s Day Parade. Students from the Middle School will be carrying
the town banner and town flag.
This month Laura will be giving her annual presentation to
the Charlton Heights 4th graders.
LIBRARY:
They had a meeting the end of April. There will be a
mortgage burning on June 4th. Councilman Lippiello will try and be
there.
PARK COMMITTEE:
Party in the Park will be the first weekend in June.
The Committee has been getting quotes for a backstop,
replacing the pavilion and repairing the warming shelter. They are also
looking at replacing the existing gazebo in Gideon Hawley Park.
Councilman Lippiello said that we have 2 quotes so far on
replacing the pavilion with a pole barn type structure with a metal roof. We
need to get a 3rd quote.
They had a walk through on Mill Pond Park. There are a
couple of things that need to be corrected. We need to be careful of parking
at Mill Pond. A resident owns the land where people were pulling in. A berm
has been made there. Parking will be parallel to Crane Street. The access is
the old roadbed.
Councilman Lippiello asked Ron to look at the plank walkway
in the park. The top planking is weak in a couple of spots. Laura said there
was a gristmill at Mill Pond.
PLANNING BOARD:
They are meeting next Monday at 7:00 P.M. They are looking for a recording secretary.
RECORDS ADVISORY BOARD:
They met a couple of weeks ago. Our new Regional Advisory
Officer David Lowry attended the meeting. We discussed what type of filing
system we might use with the records once we are in the new building and
applying for grants. Last week Gail and Laura attended and Electronic Imaging
Workshop conducted by NYS Archives.
TECHNOLOGY ADVISORY BOARD:
They had a productive meeting with the Town Clerk. John has been working with Gail.
TOWN HALL:
The consultant that we hired to do the archeological study
of the property found significant findings. We have a preliminary report and
are waiting for the Phase I Study. Unfortunately, that delays the project. We
are waiting for information regarding a Phase II Study and how it might effect
the site plan and the whole building. At our last meeting we withdrew our
resolution accessing the building fund. Councilman Grattidge and Councilman
Verola made a presentation regarding the building to the Charlton Senior’s
group. Supervisor Acunto received a correspondence from Rick Reynolds wanting
to know if some of his students could watch the dig. Councilman Verola
received an email from a resident asking the same thing. Supervisor Acunto is
concerned about risk management. Laura stated that it is required at the end
of these excavations that they do a public tour. The Board will look into it
further.
VETERAN’S RECOGNITION BOARD:
The plaques with the new names have been ordered. They have
not been put up yet.
WATER:
We will have a resolution for a watershed. We have 2 bids
on the test borings.
ZBA:
They had a hearing last month.
ZONING:
For the month of April they issued 16 permits, 2 CO’s and
collected $1,915.00. The tanks have been removed from the Getty Station on
Stage Road. There is someone who is interested in purchasing the property.
They were in Tuesday night to see what the zoning was. They would like to put
in some type of food establishment there. Dave said he explained to them the
status of the zoning there and referred them to the ZBA.
ZONING ORDINANCE REVIEW COMMITTEE:
They are on hold until the Comprehensive Planning Committee
completes its work.
RESOLUTIONS:
Motion made by Councilman Mitchell, seconded by Councilman
Grattidge that Resolution #84, A RESOLUTION APPOINTING MEMBERS TO THE RECORDS
ADVISORY BOARD, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Verola, seconded by Councilman
Grattidge that Resolution #85, A RESOLUTION RELEASING THE INDEPENDENT AUDITOR
FROM PREPARING THE GASB 34 PORTION OF THE 2004 AUDIT, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Verola, seconded by Councilman
Lippiello that Resolution #86, A RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING POLICY AND GUIDELINES
TO DEVELOP ASSEST DISTRIBUTION SCHEDULES, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Grattidge, seconded by Councilman
Mitchell that Resolution #87, A RESOLUTION RECOGNIZING CHARLTON’S DAIRY FARMING
COMMUNITY, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Lippiello, seconded by Councilman
Grattidge that Resolution #88, A RESOLUTION AMENDING RESOLUTION #115 OF THE
YEAR 1995, A RESOLUTION TO ESTABLISH A REPAIR RESERVE FUND FOR THE TOWN OF
CHARLTON WATER DISTRICT #1, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Verola, seconded by Councilman
Lippiello that Resolution #89, A RESOLUTION ACCEPTING THE TECHNOLOGY ADVISORY
BOARD’S SCOPE AND PROCEDURE, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Grattidge, seconded by Councilman
Verola that Resolution #90, A RESOLUTION ACCEPTING THE 2004 STORM WATER
MANAGEMENT PROGRAM, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Lippiello, seconded by Councilman
Verola that Resolution #91, A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE PURCHASE OF A STORAGE
SHED FOR THE CHARLTON WATER DISTRICT, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Verola, seconded by Councilman
Lippiello that Resolution #92, A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE WATER DISTRICT
SUPERINTENDENT TO PROCEED WITH DRILLING SERVICES, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Grattidge, seconded by Councilman
Verola that Resolution #93, A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE HIGHWAY DEPARTMENT TO
PURCHASE SIDING MATERIALS FOR THE SALT SHED, be approved:
Councilman Grattidge said that the original motion
authorized the expenditure of $2,000.00. We need to raise the limit to
$3,000.00.
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Lippiello, seconded by Councilman
Mitchell that Resolution #94, A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE PURCHASE OF FLOWERS
FOR THE TOWN HALL AND OTHER SITES IN TOWN, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
COUNCILMAN REPORTS:
Councilman Mitchell – Thanked Rick Reynolds, Laura Linder,
students from the BHBL Middle School and all those involved in the 14th
annual placement of flags on the veteran’s graves. Thanked those involved in
the Road Side Clean Up. The newsletter is in the mail.
Councilman Lippiello – Thanked the Highway Department the
Road Side Clean Up this year and to the ECC for the Road Side Clean Up and Tree
Give Away. Encouraged people to walk through Mill Pond Park.
Councilman Verola – Thanked the Audit Search Committee for a
job well done. Thanked the volunteers and the Highway Department for the Road
Side Clean Up.
Councilman Grattidge – This year, in conjunction with County Waste, we were able to do the whole town in three days. It has normally tied up the
Highway Department for over two weeks. The constables helped the first day with
traffic control on the main roads. County Waste provided the labor for free
and basically charged us for the cost of dumping the materials. They are
providing free brush, leaf and grass clipping pick up every Thursday. The
brush needs to be cut in 5’ lengths and tied in bundles. Leaves and grass
clippings need to be in biodegradable bags or in a separate trash can.
Party in the Park is Saturday, June 4. Their final meeting
will be on May 18 at 7:30 P.M.
On Sunday, June 5 the West Charlton Presbyterian Church has
asked to use the tents and chairs for a Sunday morning service. They are
hoping to do this on an annual basis. The public is welcome.
PRIVILEGE OF THE FLOOR:
Fran Miner – Vines Road – Said he understood that at the
Agenda Meeting, the Town Board did rescind the resolution passed last month
regarding the town hall. He said he believes that to make it legal, it should
be passed at a Town Board Meeting. Supervisor Acunto said that we did pass the
resolution at the Agenda Meeting and we have passed resolutions at the Agenda
Meeting in the past. Fran said he did not realize you could do things of that
nature at an Agenda Meeting. Supervisor Acunto said the resolution has been
rescinded. Fran asked if the petition with 281 names was taken into
consideration. Supervisor Acunto said there was no action to be taken on it.
Bob Smialek – Dawson Road – Complained about the
intersection of Dawson Road and Crane Street. He has lived in his home since
1972. He would like to have the town look at that intersection. He feels it
is dangerous. It has a grass island. There have been several close calls
there. Cars travel too fast. More homes are being built in that area and
there are more and more children on the road. He feels it is an accident
waiting to happen and the road should be straightened out by removing the
branch going to the south.
Ron said that he has received a recommendation from a New York State traffic engineer. The engineer has said the problems can be solved by
putting up stop signs. He also suggested cutting the rise that goes back into Dawson Road so traffic can see the approach easier. Ron is waiting for a written report
from the State. Ron said he believes there would be a sign on Crane Street and Dawson Road telling motorists they are approaching a stop sign. Ron has
to abide by the State Manual for Signage and get approval from the State before
he can put up signs. Supervisor Acunto said that he understood what Bob wanted
done but felt that Ron might not be able to do that under State regulations.
Marv Schorr stated that “A History of the Burnt Hills Ballston Lake School District” has been written. They are $10.00 and are available
in the Town Clerk’s Office. All proceeds go to the Burnt Hills Education
Foundation.
Chris Nelson – Sacandaga Road – Asked if the Charlton police
could patrol the Crane Street/ Dawson Road intersection.
Laura Linder – Mill Pond Park was the site of the first mill
in Charlton. It was a gristmill. They ground buckwheat flour for the making
of pancakes. The flour was of superior quality and was popular throughout the
state. There is more information on the web site.
The salutatorian for the Galway High School this year is a
Charlton resident.
Lee Bramer – West Line Road – Said that County Waste’s help with the bulk item pick up was a great asset. Their flyer that they sent
out a week ahead of time was a big help.
The next Agenda Meeting will be on Tuesday, May 31 at 7:30
P.M.
After everyone had the opportunity to speak who wish, the
meeting was adjourned at 9:00 P.M.
Respectfully
submitted,
Gail Hanchar
Town
Clerk