DRAFT
Regular Meeting March 14, 2005
Charlton Town Board
Saratoga County
New York
The meeting was called to order at 7:30 P.M. by Supervisor Acunto. One sealed bid was received for the police car. It was for
$1,500.00. We had stated in our resolution last month that we would require a
minimum bid of $2,500.00. We will have to re-bid it.
After the pledge to the flag, the invocation was given by
Town Clerk Gail Hanchar.
At the regular meeting of the Town Board of Charlton, Saratoga County, New York, held at
7:30 P.M. at the Charlton Town Hall, called to order by
Supervisor Acunto, there were present:
Councilman Alan
Grattidge
Councilman Robert
Lippiello
Councilman Dorothy
Mitchell
Councilman Sandra Verola
Supervisor Ferdinand
Acunto
Motion made by Councilman Grattidge, seconded by Councilman
Verola that the minutes of the February 14 Town Board Meeting be accepted as
received:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Grattidge, seconded by Councilman
Verola that the minutes of the February 28 Agenda Meeting be accepted as
received:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Abstain
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
ABSTRACT OF CLAIMS:
The total of the bills approved at the Agenda Meeting was
$50,830.21.
Vouchers for the month were #1152-#1254.
TOWN CLERK’S REPORT:
Gail Hanchar read the Town Clerk’s Report. She reported
taking in $94.80. Motion made by Councilman Grattidge, seconded by Councilman
Mitchell. PASSED UNANIMOUSLY.
PRIVILEGE OF THE FLOOR (Agenda items):
No comments.
SUPERVISOR’S REPORT AND ANNOUNCEMENTS:
February revenue and expenditures:
General Fund – Expenditures of $52,253.04. Revenue of
$23,845.76.
Highway Fund – Expenditures of $39,454.45. Revenue of
$75,966.77.
Water District #1 – Expenditures of $4,414.87. Revenue of
$498.19.
Water District #2 – Expenditures of $174.66. No revenue.
Major expenditures:
General Fund – Legislative Contractual of $1,360.83, Law
Contractual of $4,141.70, Building Operating of $3,841.04, Ambulance
Contractual of $5,618.75, Programs for the Aging Contractual of $1,137.50 and
Library Contractual of $13,045.00.
Highway Fund – Maintenance of Roads Contractual of
$1,463.74, Machinery Contractual of $1,448.74 and Snow Removal Contractual of
$9,624.18.
Water District - Transmission & Distribution Contractual
of $1,355.75.
Major revenue:
General Fund - Franchise Fees of $4,409.94, Interest and
Earnings of $4,816.04 and Fines and Forfeited Bail of $8,875.00.
Highway Fund - Sales Tax Distribution of $75,762.00.
There were 621 hits on the web site for the month of
February.
The Town Hall will be closed on Friday, March 25 for Good
Friday.
At the Agenda Meeting we decided that if any department
wishes to use the grant writer, they must get approval from the Town Board. A
Town Board member will contact Susan Lombardi.
We looked into the cost of printing the Senior Citizen’s
Newsletter on our town equipment. It will be $10.00 per hundred copies. They
have decided to do something other than use town equipment.
The State Police have asked for a water cooler for the
substation. The water is very poor quality. John and Ron will work together
to purchase a water cooler which will be property of the town.
The legal action regarding Swartz vs. the Town of Charlton has been set for trial in Saratoga City Court for June 6 at Noon.
There will be an E-Government Seminar at the Holiday Inn on
May 13 from 10:00 AM until Noon. They will be discussing web pages and how
they are used by different towns. It will cost $10.00 per person. We will see
if people on the E-Government Committee would like to attend.
COMMUNICATIONS:
We received a letter of resignation from the Secretary of
the Assessment Review Board.
We received a letter of resignation from Deborah Herrin,
Co-Chairman of the Comprehensive Planning Steering Committee.
We received a letter from Midge Dube, President of the
Charlton Senior Citizens, stating that they will not be using the town copy
machine. It is just as expensive as using an outside printer and they would
still need volunteers to run the copies, fold and mail. She thanked the Board
for their continued support.
ANIMAL CONTROL OFFICER
Has had some calls on dogs running at large. Dogs must be
licensed in the town. Lee is current on all of his inoculations.
ASSESSORS:
The notices with the new assessments went out today. The
Assessors will be available for the public. Residents may call or come in.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN:
Report to the Town Board
Comprehensive Planning
Steering Committee
Subcommittees & Selection
of Objectives and Strategies
March 14, 2005
At its March 7 meeting, the CPSC agreed to establish
subcommittees for the purpose of reviewing and making recommendations on
whether to accept, modify or reject our planning consultant’s proposed
Objectives and Strategies in order to meet our Vision Statement and Goals. We
also agreed on a process to use to accomplish this complex task.
As you know, the CPSC using all the various inputs provided
by our townspeople, established a Vision Statement and fourteen goals, which if
accomplished, should result in the town reaching its vision.
Our consultant, Nan, has evaluated what we have said we want
Charlton to be, and the goals sought, and has provided us a comprehensive list
of specific and detailed objectives and strategies – or required actions that
could be taken – to accomplish each goal.
Based on her education and experience, she has given us as
broad a range of choices as she can. Put another way, she has given the CPSC a
toolbox full of options, or tools to choose from. All of them are designed to
help us achieve our goals.
The job of the CPSC is to now make sure we understand the
rational or logic for each recommendation and select from the options offered
the ones the CPSC believes are a good fit for Charlton. Some of what was
suggested by the consultant may conceptually be fine, but need modification to
ultimately make them acceptable.
Once the CPSC has finished its work selecting recommended
objectives and strategies, we will hold public meetings to help educate the
public on what we are recommending and why. We will also be seeking public
feedback before we present the proposed plan to the Town Board. The Town Board
will also be holding a public hearing before it votes on the plan.
I need to make some brief comments about the subcommittees.
Every effort was made to ensure each subcommittee has equal representation from
the various demographic, economic and geographic segments of Charlton. Another
primary aim is to ensure each subcommittee is given an equal workload.
Although my wife thinks tells me I am corny, fighter pilots
tend to be that way, I have given a name to each subcommittees to honor those
that have gone before us whose deeds made a significant contribution to our
community.
The Steve Jordan Subcommittee:
Dawn Szurek (Subcommittee Coordinator)
Guy Mitchell
Doug Flynn
Deborah Herrin
Midge Dube
Assigned Goals:
- Goal 2 While respecting landowners’ rights, the town’s
rural vista/scenic views from public spaces are identified, protected and
enhanced for the enjoyment of all.
- Goal 5 The town promotes activities that enhance community
pride and citizen involvement.
- Goal 8 Quality Public Infrastructure is ecologically sound
and does not in itself induce growth and development.
- Goal 14 A Diversity of housing opportunities exist to
meet a wide variety of residential needs.
The Gideon Hawley Subcommittee:
Christy Schrader (Subcommittee Coordinator)
Richard Smith
Dave Adams
Jim Leupold
Maria McCullock
Assigned Goals
- Goal 3 The town’s environmental resources, particularly
ground water quality, quantity availability are protected.
- Goal 6 All community facilities and programs are readily
accessible and open for all residents.
- Goal 9 The town has quality, aesthetically pleasing, and
safe roads and pathways for vehicular traffic, walking and biking.
The Elmer Smith Subcommittee:
Gary Vanderhorst (Subcommittee
Coordinator)
Albert LaRue
Steve Caine
Marv Schorr
Jenna Smith
Len Wessell
Assigned Goals
- Goal 1 The town’s rural, agricultural, and aesthetic
character is protected and enhanced. Regulatory and non-regulatory land
use programs and policies guide development in Charlton to ensure that our
town remains a quality community and where future residential,
agricultural and business development is consistent with the unique
character, environment and culture of Charlton.
- Goal 7 The Hamlet serves as a primary focus for town
government, cultural and economic activities.
- Goal 12 Farmlands are protected and active farms of
varying types are economically viable and a major land use in Charlton.
The
Frank Lafforthun Subcommittee:
Sally Elms (Subcommittee Coordinator)
Dave Wood
Dean Durst
Lynda Battenhausen
Andrea Herrin
Bill Heilman
Assigned Goals
- Goal 4 Open spaces exist to protect the environment,
provide recreational benefits and to maintain the unique character of the
town.
- Goal 10 Transportation assistance is available for senior
citizens and those with special needs.
- Goal 11 Town Government is effective, responsive and
innovative.
- Goal 13 Parks, open spaces, walking and biking trails,
and diverse programs provide high quality, active and passive recreation,
and opportunities for educational and cultural development for all ages.
As a citizen, I appreciate the commitment of all CPSC
members. I would also like to express my gratitude to the four individuals
that have agreed to coordinate the activities of each of the committees.
I should also give you a brief over view of the process we
agreed for selecting recommended objectives and strategies.
Procedure for selecting
Objectives and Strategies (O/Ss)
- Each subcommittee is to meet separately and decide which
of the recommended strategies should be selected for presentation to the
full Committee for approval and record their rational. The subcommittees
also decide which O/Ss they have questions about, and which ones they have
concerns about and could reject. (Decisions are made by majority vote).
If they have a question about an O/S or consider it one they might
recommend for rejection, they must e-mail their question or the reasoning
for possible rejection to Nan, and info (CC) all other members of the
committee.
- All committee members should review the O/Ss for all
the Goals and are encourage to send any questions they may have or their
concerns (for a possible O/S rejection) to the subcommittee that is
handling the O/S that concerns them. The committee primarily
responsible for that O/S would then e-mail that question or concern (and
the rational for the concern) along to Nan with the questions, and
possible rejections (and rational) that the subcommittee generates on its
own.
- No meeting in April
- No later than April 15 -- Subcommittees should have
e-mailed all their questions and the rational for why they may recommend a
rejection to Nan, and a copy all the other committee members. This will
include questions or concerns sent to that subcommittee by members on
other subcommittees. (Majority votes used to establish a possible
rejection)
- May 2 -- The entire CPSC meets and Nan answers all the
questions that have been asked and provides her rational for suggesting
the O/Ss members are considering for rejection. Detailed minutes, as
usual, are taken and provided to all for further reference. Hopefully
this can be completed in one meeting. If we cannot finish Nan’s explanations on May 2, a second meeting in May might be attempted.
- No Later than May 28 (probably not possible if a second
meeting with Nan is required. The schedule would probably be slipped.) --
Subcommittees should have met again and completed (a) their selection (via
majority vote) of what O/Ss to recommend for acceptance or rejection and
(b) e-mailed their recommendations and the rational for each to all the
committee members, and Nan. The report to the Committee should include
the reasons for each strategy modified and/or selected, the reasons for
rejecting the strategies not recommended and any other information that
they think needs to be forwarded.
- No later than June 5 -- Every Committee member must review
all the Goals and their O/Ss, and all the reports from the subcommittees
so they can participate fully in the discussion and be fully informed on
the issues when they vote.
- June 6 -- The entire CPSC meets for voting on the
recommended acceptance or rejection of O/Ss. Subcommittees report to the
full Committee on their recommendations. Before the vote is taken to
reject any strategy, the Committee requests Nan to offer any comments she
has regarding a strategy recommended for rejection. The Committee must
consider in its overall acceptance or rejection of O/Ss the fact that some
may overlap different goals. This must be taken into account to ensure
the entire package tracks coherently before it is officially adopted.
Following completion of this activity, Nan will pull
together the first draft of the entire plan. It will then be shared with the
public and ultimately with the Town Board for a vote.
CONSTABLES:
For the month of February there were 27 patrols, answered 5
911 calls, covered 2 emergency calls, covered 2,250 miles, issued 25 tickets
and investigated 2 accidents.
ECC:
The Road Side Clean up will be Saturday, April 30 from 8:00 A.M. until Noon followed by the Tree Give Away from Noon until 1:00 P.M. We will be adding a new member to the ECC Committee.
E-GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE:
At our first meeting John Kelly and Jim Leupold were
appointed as Co-Chairman and Torben Aabo will serve as secretary. We will be
meeting again on March 22.
HIGHWAY:
The new backhoe is here.
There was a meeting with Ron regarding the road repairs that
would be coming up. He has chosen to reconstruct Lasher Road, DeGraff Road and Dawson Road. The portion of Lasher Road that will be done will be the
portion that we own up to the Ballston line. The entire length of DeGraff Road will be done from Route 67 to Western Avenue. Dawson Road will be done from
the Glenville town line to Crane Street.
There has been some concern over the intersection of Dawson Road and Crane Street. Presently there is a green triangle in the middle. Cars are
not yielding to traffic. Councilman Grattidge proposed changing the “Y”
intersection into a “T” intersection. The triangle would be removed, ditches
brought in to the normal width of a roadbed and a stop sign placed at the end
of Dawson Road. He said he had spoken with a number of the neighbors. They
are interested in seeing the intersection changed. He would like to have an
informational meeting with the neighbors to get additional input. Ron did not
feel it would be a problem to incorporate the change into the road
construction. We will be moving forward on that.
There are problems with the roof at the highway garage. It
needs to be patched or replaced.
Ron will get some estimates when the weather is better.
They have been busy with snow storms.
Supervisor Acunto asked if there had been any other
discussion about Featherbed Lane. Councilman Grattidge said Ron did some work
on it this summer and felt he had done what was needed to alleviate the
situation. We did no major reconstruction. The neighbors did not want to see
the road paved. We want to see it remain safe for the school buses.
Councilman Lippiello asked if we did any work to open the drainage a little.
Lee Bramer stated that last year they shaped up the road to give it a crown so
the road would get rid of the water. The neighbors drew up a petition because
they were concerned with us coming in and digging up ditches. They wanted to
see a single lane road as it had looked many years ago. Supervisor Acunto
stated that sometimes the needs and wants of the residents don’t coincide with
the needs and wants of the school bus superintendent and emergency services
people.
HISTORIAN:
Laura has been working on a resolution for the Stauffers. A
farewell party was given in their honor at the Historical Society by Mary
Simoni and Ethel Maloney. A resolution is a way to record our town history.
Laura attended the Planning Board Public Hearing concerning
the Town Hall. She is working on a letter explaining the history of the land
the town hall will be built on. She does not believe we will find any historic
artifacts there.
The Capital Region Archives is planning a dinner next fall.
The federal government has withdrawn funding for The
National Historic Publications and Records Commission. The Historians are
trying to get that reinstated.
Laura brought some information for the “Newcomers Packets”
for new residents.
Laura wrote a letter of recommendation for Jenna Smith. She
has been chosen as a semi-finalist for the Coca Cola Scholars Program, a
nationwide competition. There are 751 winners who will be flown to Atlanta. The finalists will each receive $20,000 in scholarships.
Laura said she is disappointed to hear that they want to
remove the island from the middle of Dawson Road. She understands the reasons
for that but it is part of historic Charlton. Each time we remove something it
takes away more of our character.
HISTORIC DISTRICT COMMISSION:
They met last month. They will be meeting again next
Wednesday. They are working on information for the web site. Supervisor Acunto
said that he read in the last minutes about going to Sue Lombardi. Make sure
that they get the information that they need to go through Dot before they
contact Sue.
LIBRARY:
Councilman Lippiello passed out copies of the 2004 Annual
Report. The library keeps growing. They issued 623 new cards which is 60%
more than before the new library was opened. There are a total of 5338
cardholders. 174,000 new items are in circulation. The library needs some
additional personnel.
PARK COMMITTEE:
They have had an application for baseball use.
PLANNING BOARD:
Their next meeting will be a week from tonight at 7:30 P.M.
The new town hall site plan is on the agenda and a number of other
subdivisions.
RECORDS ADVISORY BOARD:
The Board met last week. Two books were
chosen to be preserved this year. We will be discussing grants for the vault
including supplies, labor, shelving, etc. We would like the other town offices
to know that we are here to help them with proper storage of records. We would
like to designate one day a year as a day when offices would transfer any
necessary records to the vault. We would like to see space designated in the
basement where our records management clerk or any departments can work on
records outside of the vault. We currently have one vacancy on the Board. If
anyone is interested they can contact Gail, Dot or Laura. Our next meeting
will be April 28 at 7:30 P.M. We are hoping to have Dave Lowry, our Regional
Advisory Officer attend. Several of us planned to attend a workshop at Saratoga County on Electronic Document Imaging but it was cancelled due to the weather.
Laura stated that the Records Advisory Board is responsible for all town
records. We are generating records all the time. We should all work together
on the type of storage and furniture we will have.
TECHNOLOGY ADVISORY BOARD:
They are working on their charter. They have had a couple
of requests from different employees to look at problems with software and
hardware.
Councilman Lippiello asked if it was necessary for the
Technology Advisory Board and the E-Government Board to come back to the Town
Board with their charter. Councilman Verola said she felt they should come to
the Board so they can review it and make sure they doing what the Board wants
them to do. At some point the Technology Board and E-Government Board will
have a joint meeting. (Changed tape) George Eggleston asked if a member of
the Technology Board could attend the upcoming E-Government Seminar. It was
decided we will ask the members if they want to attend.
TOWN HALL:
They are continuing on the site plan. There will be an
Informational Meeting on Monday,
March 28 at 7:00 P.M. This is before the Agenda Meeting.
We will be presenting our final design and providing information for how the
town proposes to pay for it. There will be no town tax. Financial Consultant
Jeanine Caruso, Architect Paul Vosburgh and Town Attorney Bob VanVranken will
be present.
VETERAN’S RECOGNITION BOARD:
We are still collecting names. The new names will be on the
board before the Memorial Day service. Councilman Lippiello said there had
been some questions regarding people who have served in the Guards. Several
veterans have indicated to Estella they would prefer not to have Guards names
included along with those who have served in the armed forces.
WATER:
He is continuing with daily testing for the NYS Department
of Health. Readings of residual chlorination remain about the same. She has
not made a determination if we will need to go to chlorination or not. The
Department of Health is now requiring us to do some of the same testing as
Glenville. Jim Mitchell, our town engineer, has been in contact with an
engineer with the Division of Water in ENCON. Councilman Lippiello read a
proposed letter from Jim Mitchell to ENCON asking for permission for the town
to file a water supply application once a year and include all individuals that
have been connected during the year. The letter was approved by Bob
VanVranken. The Board gave permission for Jim to mail the letter. It is the
same procedure that we followed last year.
ZBA:
They will be hearing an application for an area variance in
April.
ZONING ADMINISTRATOR:
For the month of February they issued 3 building permits, 9
CO’s and collected $848.00.
Dave said he received a call from ENCON today about the bulk
storage facility at the Getty Station on Stage Road. They are in violation of
a bulk storage facility permit.
RESOLUTIONS:
Motion made by Councilman Grattidge, seconded by Councilman
Verola that Resolution #71, A RESOLUTION APPOINTING JAY WILKINSON AS AN
ALTERNATE MEMBER TO THE PLANNING BOARD, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Grattidge, seconded by Councilman
Verola that Resolution #72, A RESOLUTION APPOINTING LANE JASTREBSKI AS A MEMBER
OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION COMMISSION, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
Motion made by Councilman Grattidge, seconded by Councilman
Verola that Resolution #73, A RESOLUTION TO ENTER INTO A CONTRACT WITH
WILLIAMS, MCMANUS AND RICCIARDELLI, P.C., be approved:
Councilman Grattidge asked if the price included the
justices. Supervisor Acunto said the original quote was $1,500.00 less. They
charged $750.00 for each justice bringing the total to $6,600.00.
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
The resolution for the sale of the police car will not be
passed. It was determined we will discuss at the agenda meeting what we would
do regarding the sale of the car.
Motion made by Councilman Mitchell, seconded by Councilman
Grattidge that Resolution #74, A RESOLUTION APPOINTING CHRISTINA BUBLAK AS A
MEMBER OF THE RECORDS ADVISORY BOARD, be approved:
Approved: Councilman
Grattidge Yes
Councilman
Lippiello Yes
Councilman
Mitchell Yes
Councilman
Verola Yes
Supervisor
Acunto Yes
COUNCILMAN REPORTS:
Supervisor Acunto - Congratulated the Burnt Hills Ballston
Lake Girls and Boys Basketball Teams for successful seasons this year. There
are 5 young ladies from Charlton that play on the girl’s team.
Councilman Verola – I want to make it understood that the
reason that the Town Board has agreed to do the audit and contract with this
company is that our primary concern is our internal controls and our
procedures. No one, and I believe I can speak for the whole Board, thinks that
anyone is doing anything wrong. There is no suspicion there. There is no
concern there. Our concern is strictly with our procedures and making sure
that we are up to date in the year 2005.
Councilman Grattidge – Party in the Park will meet Wednesday
at 7:00 P.M. Everything is progressing well.
Bulk Item Pick Up will be May 2-6. We are working
cooperation with County Waste. We will be picking up household furniture,
TV’s, computers, mattresses, air conditioners, lawn mowers, glass, all metals,
washers, dryers and hot water tanks. We cannot take brush, demolition
materials, paint, motor vehicles, engines, tires, propane tanks and any
hazardous materials. County Waste will pick up leaves, brush and grass
clippings from every resident from April 7 – December 1. Pick up will be every
Thursday. Brush must be cut in 5-foot lengths and tied into bundles. Grass
clippings and leaves and can be put in biodegradable bags or in open topped
trash containers.
The Park Committee and the Historic District Commission
should get together before the town hall project is undertaken to discuss how
the walking path and the lighting pattern is going to work in the existing town
park and adapted on. There should probably be some changes in the fence.
We need to do something with the landscaping around the salt
shed when the roof work is completed.
Councilman Mitchell – The deadline for the next newsletter
is April 14. Thanked Deborah Herrin for serving as Co-Chair of the
Comprehensive Plan Steering Committee. Thanked Chris Nelson for her work with
the Assessment Review Board.
Councilman Lippiello – Thanked Deborah for Co-Chairing the
Planning Committee and her time commitment.
PRIVILEGE OF THE FLOOR:
Steve Caine – Charlton Road – I am a veteran of active duty
having served in Viet Nam. I feel very strongly as an active duty veteran………my
son is a guardsman who has been in two wars. We have guardsmen dying with
regularity right now. If any of these guardsmen or women were called to active
duty they would be there in a flash just like active duty. I heard what I
considered small reasons for not having them on the Board. These are patriots
just like anybody else and if they are called upon they are there. (Could not
understand). These people get an honorable discharge and serve their country
and if they haven’t gone to war, they deserve to be on there.
Laura stated that the Erie Canal is now a National Heritage
Corridor. Brookside Museum is trying to raise funding. It is our Saratoga County Museum. You can buy a brick in their walkway. We will be placing the
Memorial Day flags on the veteran’s graves on Saturday, May 7.
The Agenda Meeting is on March 28. It is scheduled for 7:30
P.M. but will probably start later because of the Informational Meeting at 7:00
P.M.
After everyone had the opportunity to speak who wished, the
meeting was adjourned at 8:50 P.M.
Respectfully
submitted,
Gail
Hanchar
Town
Clerk